For instance, if Maro was hit by such an effect, its power and toughness would be undefined. Effects such as “Target creatures loses all abilities” should be placed in Layer 5. This page was last edited on 8 November 2020, at 13:05. Continuous effects apply in a series of layers. Unless it says otherwise, all objects are face up and untapped.Example 1, The following effects are applied in chronological order to your Benalish Cavalry, The following effects are applied in chronological order to your Gray Ogre with a +1/+1 counter on it, Example 3 (Warning: Beyond the realms of realism) That would mean it would always look at its owner’s graveyard, which makes no sense. If you’re a visual learner, you may want to check out the conference presentations page, where you can find my presentation about continuous effects. Conspiracy depends upon Life and Limb because applying Life and Limb first makes the Forest into a creature, increasing the number of permanents Conspiracy applies to. That wouldn’t make any sense! You'll notice that there are six layers and that the final layer (power and toughness effects) is split into five sub-layers. The most common issue is mistakenly identifying an ability-adding effect as a text-changing effect. If you can spot the word ‘Copy’ in the ability/spell text, then it’s fairly safe to say that the effect needs to live here. Nothing is more intricately intertwined with the reputation of a rules expert than a solid knowledge of continuous effects. If a continuous effect begins to apply in one layer or sublayer, all parts of that effect will apply to the same set of objects in each subsequent layer or sublayer, even if the set of objects it wants to apply to changes or it loses the ability generating that effect during the process. If you really aren’t a creative type, one of the best I’ve heard is the “three C’s of judging”: Commander, Clean Table Trash, Complain About Players. If you have any questions about this topic or feedback on this article, I'd welcome it (nick@dcijudge.co.uk). Example: Master Thief has the ability “When Master Thief enters the battlefield, gain control of target artifact for as long as you control Master Thief.” If you lose control of Master Thief before the ability resolves, it does nothing, because its duration—as long as you control Master Thief—was over before the effect began. For example. Q: Amy controls a Night of Souls’ Betrayal and casts a Grizzly Bears. This question was specially selected to illustrate certain concepts (a dependency involving the set of affected objects changing, dependency loops, the set of objects a continuous effect applies to not changing even if new objects want to join that set along the way) and isn’t related to actual Magic: the Gathering in any way. It was part of the object when it was created.). What is the shapeshifter’s p/t? The goal of the continuous effects system is to make it so the answer to any continuous effects question is what we would intuitively expect as often as possible. In layer 7, there are two competing effects trying to set Humility’s p/t; Humility wants it to be 1/1, an Opalescence wants it to be 4/4. You have a starting value (your original object), a number of values to combine in some way (your effects) and hopefully at some point an answer. Q: Amy enchants Nicole’s Volrath’s Shapeshifter with Control Magic. A continuous effect may be generated by the resolution of a spell or ability. On the other hand, Life and Limb also depends upon Conspiracy because applying Conspiracy first makes Gutter Skulk a Saproling, increasing the number of permanents Life and Limb applies to. Applying Urborg first doesn’t change anything about what Blood Moon will do, but applying Blood Moon before Urborg will make Urborg into a Mountain, removing its abilities. What categories would the following cards fall … There are other kinds of continuous effects that don’t have to do with setting an object’s characteristics, and so don’t fit into the layers. How big are the other creatures?

Nasa Space Grant Asu, Epics Gold Asu, Lysa Terkeurst Family, Wells Ice Cream, 6 Square Meters In Length And Width, Equatorial Stars Astronomy, Nongshim Shin Bowl Review, Undefeated Air Max 90 Anthracite, Spicules In Sponges, Is Avocado Healthy, Cheap Single Beds For Sale, Tokyo Imperial Palace Interior, Gorgonzola Vs Blue Cheese, Hazelnut Latte: Starbucks Recipe, Easy Chicken Piccata, Last Of Us 2 Review Spoilers Reddit, Renegade Styx Piano, Model United Nations Conferences 2019, Maxwell House Coffee, Gordon Ramsay Steak Recipe Grill, Apocalypto Amazon Prime, Volume Trading Strategy,